Collie vs Saint Shepherd Comparison. Which dog is better for you: Collie or St. Shepherd?

Compare the Collie and Saint Shepherd breeds to identify their similarities and differences. Are you trying to decide between a Collie or a St. Shepherd? Read on to determine which breed is the better fit for you

Differences only

Other names

English Collie, Lassie Dog, Collie, Long-Haired Collie, Scottish Collie

St. Shepherd

Weight

What is the average weight of Collie and Saint Shepherd?

67.5 pounds ( 31 kg )

122.5 pounds ( 56 kg )

Height

What is the average height of Collie and Saint Shepherd

25.0 inches ( 63.5 cm )

29.5 inches ( 74.9 cm )

Hypoallergenic

Are Collies or Saint Shepherds hypoallergenic, or neither?

Unfortunately, neither Collie nor Saint Shepherd are hypoallergenic, which may not make them the best choice for dog lovers who suffer from pet allergies.

Temperament

What are the personalities of Collie and Saint Shepherd dogs?

Friendly
Gentle
Intelligent
Loyal
Protective
Responsive
Social
Hard working
Docile
Obedient
Elegant
Herding

Curious
Independent
Happy
Alert
Courageous
Intelligent
Confident
Friendly
Obedient
Loyal
Gentle
Going
Social
Watchful
Quiet

Shedding Level

Do Collies shed more than Saint Shepherds, or which breed sheds more, Collies or Saint Shepherds?

Collie or Saint Shepherd dogs are extremely heavy shedders, they will lose a large amount of hair each year. To decrease the amount of shedding, you can regularly brush your Collie or Saint Shepherd.

Origin

What is the origin of Collie and Saint Shepherd dog breeds?

United Kingdom

United States

Ancestry

What are the origins of Collie and Saint Shepherd breeds?

Collie, Sheepdog

German Shepherd, Saint Bernard

Breed recognition

Which kennel clubs recognize/register Collie and Saint Shepherd?

American Canine Registry
American Kennel Club
America's Pet Registry
Canadian Kennel Club
Dog Registry of America Inc.
Federation Cynologique Internationale
Kennel Club of Great Britain
North American Purebred Registry, Inc.
American Canine Association, Inc.
Australian National Kennel Council
Continental Kennel Club
National Kennel Club
New Zealand Kennel Club
United Kennel Club

DRA = Dog Registry of America, Inc.

Date of Birth

When were Collie and Saint Shepherd breeds first developed?

1800s

2000s

Eye Color Possibilites

What are the eye colors of Collie and Saint Shepherd dogs?

Brown

Nose Color Possibilites

What are the natural nose colors of Collie and Saint Shepherd?

Black

Coat Color Possibilites

What are the natural colors of the coat for Collie and Saint Shepherd breeds?

Black
Sable
Blue

Black
Brown
Pied
Sable

Coat Length

What is the typical coat length for Collie and Saint Shepherd breeds?

The coat of Collie and Saint Shepherd dogs is longer than that of the typical dog.

Coat Density

What is the density of the coat of Collie and Saint Shepherd?

Coat Texture

What is the hair texture of Collie and Saint Shepherd?

Straight

Litter Size

What is the usual litter size for Collie and Saint Shepherd?

14-16 puppies per pregnancy

A Collie can have a litter of 14-16 puppies on average. However, it's worth noting that the size of the litters can vary greatly. Factors that can influence litter size include the health of the mother, breeding history, and genetics.

6-10 puppies per pregnancy

A Saint Shepherd can have a litter of 6-10 puppies on average. However, it's worth noting that the size of the litters can vary greatly. Factors that can influence litter size include the health of the mother, breeding history, and genetics.

Adaptability

Collies are known for their adaptability and can adjust well to different environments and lifestyle changes.

Saint Shepherds are highly adaptable and versatile, making them excellent companions for families and individuals of all lifestyles.

Health Issues

Between Collie and Saint Shepherd, which breed is more prone to health problems?

While the Collie breed is generally healthy, occasional vet check-ups are still necessary to address any health concerns.

The Saint Shepherd breed is generally very healthy, requiring minimal vet visits. Still, it's important to keep an eye on their health and seek veterinary care when needed.

Major Concerns

What are the major health concerns for Collie and Saint Shepherd breeds?

Progressive Retinal Atrophy
Hip Dysplasia
Collie Eye Anomaly

Hip And Elbow Dysplasia
Renal Cystadenocarcinoma and Nodular Dermatofibrosis
Dilated Cardiomyopathy (DCM)
Gastric Dilation Volvulus (GDV) or Bloat

Minor Concerns

What minor health issues should be kept in mind when owning Collie and Saint Shepherd?

Allergies
Skin Problems
Dermatomyositis
Nasal Solar Dermatitis

Entropion
Ectropion
Pannus
Keratoconjunctivitis Sicca (Dry Eye)

Occasional Tests

What occasional tests are recommended for Collie and Saint Shepherd breeds?

Eye
Blood Test
(Dna Test For Pra)
Physical Examination
Allergy Tests

Eye Examination
Skin Evaluation
Blood And Urine Analysis
Diagnostic Imaging
Cardiac Test

Social Needs

Collie vs Saint Shepherd social needs comparison

Collie has very high social needs and requires regular mental and physical stimulation, a job or purpose, and companionship.

Saint Shepherd has above average social needs and thrives with interaction with humans and other dogs.

Sleeping Need

Which of the two sleeps the most/least: Collie or Saint Shepherd?

Collie and Saint Shepherd breeds are known to have moderate energy levels and normal sleep patterns, typically sleeping around 12-14 hours per day.

Mouthiness

Mouthiness Comparison: Collie vs Saint Shepherd?

Roaming urge

Collie vs Labrador: Running away tendency?

Prey Drive

Collie or Saint Shepherd - which breed has a higher level of prey drive?

Past times

What are some enjoyable activities and ways to keep Collie and Saint Shepherd entertained?

Walks, Training, Tasking, Public Access, Walk, Run, Playing, Petting, Walking, Eating Snacks, Runnig, Snow, Fetch, Runn, Feeding, Going on walks, Camping, Hiking, Swimming

Fetch, Napping, Running, Walking, Tug-of-war, Hiking, Movie marathons, Frisbee, Walks, Hunting, Swimming, Traveling, Run, Tricks, Chase, Walk, Play keep away, Play, Playdate, Water play, Hide & Seek, Playing fetch, Hike, Tag, Walkin, Play time, Training, Sleeping, Swim, Brushing

Activity Level

Which breed has higher energy, Collies or Saint Shepherds?

Medium

Collies are medium-energy dogs and typically enjoy socializing and playing casual or even sustained games of chase with other dogs. They may also have occasional periods of barking or racing around the house.

High

Saint Shepherds are high-energy dogs. They need mental as well as physical exercise. These dogs require a lot of your involvement and without it they can, and will, become problematic dogs.

Tolerance of being left alone

Walks per Week

How many miles should Collie or Saint Shepherd walk each week?

10 miles / week

There's really no limit to how far you walk your dog as long as they're comfortable. For Collie, it's at least 10 miles / week. Just remember to build distance and stamina gradually over time.

18 miles / week

There's really no limit to how far you walk your dog as long as they're comfortable. For Saint Shepherd, it's at least 18 miles / week. Just remember to build distance and stamina gradually over time.

Activity per Day

Do Collies or Saint Shepherds require more exercise?

45 minutes

In general most Collies usually need at least 45 minutes of exercise daily. This can be spread across the day and include all sorts of high-energy activities, like walking, running and playing.

90 minutes

In general most Saint Shepherds usually need at least 90 minutes of exercise daily. This can be spread across the day and include all sorts of high-energy activities, like walking, running and playing.

Grooming

Which breed is easier to maintain in terms of grooming, Collies or Saint Shepherds?

Collies have high grooming needs, requiring regular trims and professional grooming assistance to keep their coat healthy.

The Saint Shepherd requires an average amount of grooming compared to other breeds.

Brushing Frequency

What is the recommended brushing frequency for Collie and Saint Shepherd dogs?

Weekly

Collie should be brushed at least once a week. Of course you can give them more frequent brushes if you find that they are still shedding a lot

Daily

Ideally, Saint Shepherd should be brushed at least 2 or 3 times a week (preferably daily) improve shedding.

Brushing Tools

What brushing tools are used for Collies and Saint Shepherds?

Pin Brush
Comb
Nail Clipper

Pin Brush
Comb
Deshedder
Nail Clipper

Cups

How much food should be given to Collie or Saint Shepherd in cups?

3.2 cups

For an average 60-75 pound (27 - 34 kg) Collie feed 3.2 cups daily. But, keep in mind, the amount you feed is going to be dependent on the quality of the food you are feeding.

4.5 cups

For an average 95-150 pound (43 - 68 kg) Saint Shepherd feed 4.5 cups daily. But, keep in mind, the amount you feed is going to be dependent on the quality of the food you are feeding.

Daily Cost

Which breed has a higher daily cost, Collie or Saint Shepherd?

$2.10 - $2.70 / day

The average cost of a Collie is somewhere $2.10 - $2.70 per day.

$4.50 - $5.60 / day

The average cost of a Saint Shepherd is somewhere $4.50 - $5.60 per day.

Monthly Cost

Which breed has a higher monthly cost, Collie or Saint Shepherd?

$55 - $73 / month

The average per month expenses of a Collie is between $55 - $73. This makes an average of $660 - $876 per year. It will be on the higher side when the dog is still small because it will need more frequent visits to the vet, shots.

$134 - $168 / month

The average per month expenses of a Saint Shepherd is between $134 - $168. This makes an average of $1608 - $2016 per year. It will be on the higher side when the dog is still small because it will need more frequent visits to the vet, shots.

Sensitivity Level

How do Collie and Saint Shepherd compare in sensitivity?

These dog breeds are particularly attuned to its environment and the emotions of those around it. Collie and Saint Shepherd can be easily overwhelmed by loud noises, new environments, unfamiliar people, or animals. This dog breed is best suited for individuals or families who are patient, gentle, and understanding of its sensitive nature. It may also benefit from a calm and stable home environment, with a consistent routine and plenty of positive reinforcement training.

Apartment Friendly

Which breed is more apartment-friendly: Collie or Saint Shepherd?

Collies and Saint Shepherds are dogs that do well in apartments with sufficient exercise, but they would really appreciate a small yard.

Child Friendly

Do Collies or Saint Shepherds have a friendlier temperament towards children?

The typical characteristics of Collie and Saint Shepherd indicate that this breed of dog is an ideal companion for kids and makes them family pets. Their gentle and protective nature and calm mentality make them gel along quickly with the younger humans.

Senior-friendly

Which dog is more suitable as a pet for the elderly - Collie or Saint Shepherd?

Cat Friendly

Do Collie or Saint Shepherd breeds have a better compatibility with cats?

Collies are very friendly with cats and make great companions for them.

Saint Shepherds are good with cats, but early training is needed to prevent chasing behavior.

Dog Friendly

Which breed is more sociable with other dogs: Collie or Saint Shepherd?

Collies and Saint Shepherds are friendly, active and loyal companions. They generally love to be around other dogs, making them a good family pet for some.

Pet friendly

How do Collie or Saint Shepherd dogs interact with other pets?

Stranger Friendly

Which breed is more friendly with strangers: Collie or Saint Shepherd?

Collie and Saint Shepherd are friendly dogs and typically won't bark at strangers. However, if you wish to change this behavior, training them is easy thanks to their intelligence, making it pretty simple to teach them anything.

Playfulness

Which breed is more playful between Collie and Saint Shepherd?

Collies are a playful breed that needs daily playtime to be happy.

Saint Shepherds have an average level of playfulness, enjoying playtime like most dogs but not excessively so.

Trainability

How do the trainability levels of Collies and Saint Shepherds compare?

The Collie is highly intelligent and eager to please, making it a great choice for both novice and experienced dog owners due to its easy trainability.

Saint Shepherds are usually easy to train but require consistency to fully obey commands.